National Contest Judges’ Information

The National History Day Contest will be held June 11-15, 2017 at the University of Maryland at College Park. National History Day (NHD) is looking for historians, educators, and others to judge student projects at this year’s contest. Judging will take place on Monday, June 12 for the Junior Division (grades 6-8) and Tuesday, June 13 for the Senior Division (grades 9-12).

Students in 6th through 12th grades conduct extensive research on topics related to an annual theme and present their findings in historical papers, exhibits, documentaries, performances, and websites.

Evaluation and discussion with your fellow judges will be an all-day commitment from approximately 8:00 a.m. to 5:00 p.m. In return for your time and effort, we offer free parking and lunch, endless gratitude, and a positive perspective on our nation’s youth.

Sign Up to Judge
What to Expect on Judging Day
Judging Process
Judging Criteria
Sign Up to Judge

If you have any questions, please contact judges@nhd.org.

The 2017 National Contest judging roster is now full. If you are interested in being placed on our waiting list, please complete the survey with your preferences. If a spot opens, you will be contacted.

If you are interested in the website and/or paper categories, you will be contacted with additional information regarding the specific judging process for those categories.

Please note: If you would like to judge for your local or affiliate NHD contest, please contact your affiliate coordinator.

Judging Survey 2017
What to Expect on Judging Day

If you are confirmed as a National Contest judge, you will receive detailed instructions and materials to help you prepare for your busy days. The morning begins with a judging orientation and meeting your fellow judges.

Entries are scheduled at specific time intervals, depending on which category you are judging. There will be a lunch break midday. You will complete evaluations for each entry and submit other paperwork.

After the last entry in your judging group has finished, you and your judging teammates will discuss comments and ratings, and come to a conclusion about the final overall rankings for the entries in your group.*

At the end of the day you will be tired, but refreshed with the spirit of youth who value history and are eager for your feedback about their year-long projects.

We sincerely hope that you are interested in judging at the national contest. Please contact us if you are interested in being a judge.

*The process described here varies for the website and paper categories. If you are interested in these categories, the process will be explained to you.

Judging Process

NHD relies on consensus judging. That means that instead of giving entries numeric scores, you will be ranking them. If you are confirmed as a judge, you will be assigned to a team of 3 judges, one of whom will be designated as the captain. It is important that everyone on your team agrees on the overall rankings of the entries you judge.

Judging Criteria

Historical Quality (60%)

  • Historical accuracy
  • Historical context
  • Analysis and interpretation
  • Use of available primary sources
  • Wide research
  • Balanced research

Relation to Theme (20%)

  • Clearly relates to theme
  • Demonstrates significance of topic in history and draws conclusions

Clarity of Presentation (20%)

  • Presentation, written materials are original, clear, appropriate, organized and articulate
  • Entry is organized; visual impact is appropriate to topic

Below are the Judging Instructions for each category, which confirmed judges will receive with their assignments:

Documentary | Exhibit | Paper | Performance | Website
Contest Rule Book English
Contest Rule Book Spanish
Sample Evaluation Forms